The catch and release issue is back.

ill Photo FB

STORSLETT: Salmon fishermen in Reisa River are force due to local bye laws to release all fish over 80 cm long (5kg) but this has caused quiet a stir among activists and their lawyers.

skot

The new regulations can be a direct violation of Norways animal protection act. Now lawyers that represent Statens dyrehelsetilsyn have reacted and are considering action to stop this new trend. Helen Stenevik who is one of the represents of this group claim that the number of deaths caused by “catch and release” are far to high to accept this as a conservation method for the wild salmon populations.

Statistics are mixed.

Each of the major studies has shown that there is no concrete figure of what percentage of fish die after been released. A resent study showed that only five present of fish die after being released but this is hotly debated issue. From a conservationists point of view this is a fantastic result. Yet local river owner Jan Tørfoss has claimed that it is not that uncommon to see large salmon floating down stream dead. Until a complete study on how to release fish or what is the best way to manage “catch and release” is complete all parties involved in the issue will continue to bitch.

Famous case studies.

There have been many famous case studies to follow. New Zealand and Northern Russia come to mind. Here is an example of two exclusive catch and release fisheries that have over time proven that this technique leads to an improved fish stock. Norway is often slow to see other examples at work but thanks to many foresighted landowners this is the future here. Many of these lawyers that protect the “rights” of fish are looking at the big picture. In order to protect the interests of two parties certain compromises need to be made.

What can we do?

We sports fishermen have a responsibility to protect the future of sports fishing. The ability to save entire gene stocks is beyond the average fisherman but the simplest act may go a long way in helping researchers undergo a daunting task. I for one agree with this landowner’s policy but I understand the only way these activists can claim any sort of victory is through education and concrete prove that this works !!! In fact the river manager has asked for funding to help build a hatchery but in the mean time the only solution is to continue with the current program.